I've Just done this quest a few min ago. You can kill any one of the three Sahagin and get the key item. And they are all True Sound. We killed Kappa Biwa and got the Key item. Solo-able by a 75WHM/NIN, 75RDM. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Araushnee (talk • contribs).
I did this today as BST and used the zone method. I came back out and killed the WHM (Bonze) easily. I went back to the ??? and saw that a party had killed the other two already. I checked the ??? and it said that nothing was out of the ordinary. I waited a bit, then respawned, zoned, came back, and fought the MNK (Akuso) until his HP was pretty low, maybe 20%. I zoned when he 2-houred and killed my pet. I came back, and he was at full HP. Unless he regens very quickly, I suspect that the party had been aggravating the WHM. I checked widescan and saw only the MNK and BRD up. I fought the MNK, and the BRD disappeared from widescan. After finishing off the MNK (still no sign of the BRD), I was able to get the key item from the ???.
Though it's supposedly been confirmed that you can kill just the WHM and get the key item, this did not work for me, probably because the party messed up the quest. Just a caveat: don't let s others interfere with these NMs. --Sivara 16:05, 9 March 2008 (UTC)
It seems as if the main page has been overly-cluttered by testimonials, which belong in the discussion page...I recommend the testimonials be moved here, or more or less deleted. --Docstu 07:35, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
- done. i took out most of them, and simply said it was soloable by most 75 jobs /nin. i also removed the 2 lines saying killing each specific one was confirmed on whatever date. it doens't really need to be said, as it applies to ALL quests/missions that pop more then one mob (any one must be killed, and the rest must depop before it's killed).