Talk: Iron Anvil III (Windurst)

Latest revision as of 18:09, 25 January 2009

Proof of 8 ingredient requirement http://i162.photobucket.com/albums/t273/Nynjaaa/img_20080121_131110.jpg That sucked, things didnt even go in order: Beak -> Blood -> Beak...ugh. Was certain I was going time out on that one. --Nynja 18:14, 21 January 2008 (UTC)

For the comment about needing skill in the craft, how was this tested? Did the person in question get the quest from Emhi then when talking to the Adjucant only have the option for Woodworking? Or is this based upon not being able to get the Op from Emhi? If it's the latter I believe the poster may be mistaken. I personally have not been able to get any of these ops lately as they have been unavailable in Windy every time I've checked. --Syeria 22:49, 29 January 2008 (UTC)

Late response, but... I tried to do Alchemy and Clothcraft (both of which I have in the low 20s), and Cooking (which I have at 30), but the Adjutant gave me a message for all 3 saying that I didn't have enough skill in those crafts. I was able to do Woodworking, however, which I have at 44. --Kyrie 01:44, 9 June 2008 (UTC)

Cooking 41 was sufficient to obtain this op. Aarre 04:18, 11 June 2008 (UTC)

do we really need to list out all 8 ingredients?

now that the recipes in this quest are getting harder (more items in recipe) it seems the norm on this page to list out each and every ingredient, even when the recipe would list simpler if the page used quantities (like on the recipe page). this becomes more apparent when the items in a large recipe are not in order, and the time is limited.

for example:

Linen Doublet - Earth Crystal + Saruta Cotton + Saruta Cotton + Saruta Cotton + Linen Thread + Linen Cloth + Linen Cloth + Linen Cloth + Linen Cloth

... or ...

Linen Doublet - Earth Crystal + 3x Saruta Cotton + Linen Thread + 4x Linen Cloth

personally, i think the second one is much easier to read, and easier to keep track of. any thoughts / preferences? [ Kaia 22:02, 24 March 2008 (UTC) ]

Just did five star version and adjusted value accordingly. May not be the absolute maximum however.--Rsrlawman 18:09, 25 January 2009 (UTC)

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 For the comment about needing skill in the craft, how was this tested? Did the person in question get the quest from Emhi then when talking to the Adjucant only have the option for Woodworking? Or is this based upon not being able to get the Op from Emhi? If it's the latter I believe the poster may be mistaken. I personally have not been able to get any of these ops lately as they have been unavailable in Windy every time I've checked. --[[User:Syeria|Syeria]] 22:49, 29 January 2008 (UTC)
+:Late response, but... I tried to do Alchemy and Clothcraft (both of which I have in the low 20s), and Cooking (which I have at 30), but the Adjutant gave me a message for all 3 saying that I didn't have enough skill in those crafts. I was able to do Woodworking, however, which I have at 44. --[[User:Kyrial|Kyrie]] 01:44, 9 June 2008 (UTC)
+Cooking 41 was sufficient to obtain this op. [[User:Aarre|Aarre]] 04:18, 11 June 2008 (UTC)
 == do we *really* need to list out all 8 ingredients? ==
-now that the recipes in this quest are getting harder (more items in recipe) it seems the norm on this page to list out each and every ingredient, even when the recipe would list simpler if the page used quantities (like on the recipe page) ie:
+now that the recipes in this quest are getting harder (more items in recipe) it seems the norm on this page to list out each and every ingredient, even when the recipe would list simpler if the page used quantities (like on the recipe page). this becomes more apparent when the items in a large recipe are not in order, and the time is limited.
+for example:
 * [[Linen Doublet]] - {{Earth|Crystal}} + Saruta Cotton + Saruta Cotton + Saruta Cotton + Linen Thread + Linen Cloth + Linen Cloth + Linen Cloth + Linen Cloth
@@ Line 17: / Line 21: @@
 personally, i think the second one is much easier to read, and easier to keep track of. any thoughts / preferences? [ [[User:Kaia9|Kaia]] 22:02, 24 March 2008 (UTC) ]
+Just did five star version and adjusted value accordingly.  May not be the absolute maximum however.--[[User:Rsrlawman|Rsrlawman]] 18:09, 25 January 2009 (UTC)