I did the same questions as my friend, and we both ended up with needing the same item. I would think the answers are set to a specific item then. As another friend answered differently and got a different item --- Divimise
I think the answers are set to a specific item depending on some factors... perhaps day of the week? Because, you see, Maelstrome picked the third option for all six questions on Firesday and got asked to get a Gold Beastcoin. My friend picked all third options on Watersday (around mid-day, 12:00) and got asked to get Lynx Meat. At the same time, I picked all second options and got asked to get Nyumomo doll. Alth Aaiaa 23:01, 14 January 2009 (UTC)
Picked: Unknown Breed, Coarse paws, Culinary Delights, Green Eyes, Meowww, and Cuteness. Asked for: Nyumomo doll 7:55 Lightningsday --JTimmons 22:03, 8 December 2008 (UTC)
Picked (lightningsday, ~17:00):'A cat, yet, not a cat','Irresistibly soft','High Places','Green, with envy','Meowww','Savageness' and also got the Nyumomo Doll
just tryed to get this before completeing the Windurst quest A Feast for Gnats, and could not get mission, the tavern door just said "The door is firmly locked". You do need to finnish your nations quest strands to open this mission. JAYMZ 22:48, 8 December 2008 (UTC)
Has anyone tried to check if the answers are presented in the same order each time ? The item could be answer related but knowing if the answers are in the same order would help in understanding the inconsistency in the article (Always 3rd option gives lynx meat). Carlie 11:09, 9 December 2008 (UTC)
I got asked for the doll, i wish SE would increase the drop rate on the doll as orcs in the downs are now just being overfarmed horrendously --Lacas 15:03, 9 December 2008 (UTC)
I took all 3rd options to answer the six questions on Firesday: 1. A cat, yet, not a cat 2. Unpleasantly coarse 3. Culinary delights 4. Green, with envy, 5. Meeow, 6. A pair of knee-high bottes. And the NPC wants me one Gold beastcoin. Maelstorme 16:15, 9 December 2008 (UTC)
cat, yet not/firm/high/yellow/kupo/cuteness - Nyumomo Doll --Valyana 17:07, 9 December 2008 (UTC)
I answered the following on Lightsday, Full Moon: 1.A Mithran child 2.Irresistibly soft 3.Culinary delights 4.Green with envy 5.Meowww 6.Cuteness. Result was a Nyumomo Doll. --FFXI-Guppy 22:26, 9 December 2008 (UTC)
I used the gold beastcoin answers on the front page 3 times on 3 different characters at different times of day and got gold beastcoin. Shentok 01:11, 14 December 2008 (UTC)
I also picked the 3rd option on every question just as Maelstorme did, and I was asked to get a Gold beastcoin. This might be the ticket to avoiding the doll. --MishaRamuh
I got Beastcoin as well from same line of answers as Maelstorme.
I did the same answers as Maelstorme, except I chose "the almighty gil" for answer number three on Watersday, Waning Gibbous 90%, and I got lynx meat. Valandra 01:46, 10 December 2008 (UTC)
On Watersday, I picked the same as Maelstorme. 1. A cat, yet, not a cat 2. Unpleasantly coarse 3. Culinary delights 4. Green, with envy, 5. Meeow, 6. A pair of knee-high bottes. I got Lynx Meat.Nobodyreal 02:00, 10 December 2008 (UTC)
I picked the last choice on each choice and got Lynx Meat, I was with 2 others that did the same and also got the same. So its a good bet that everyone that does that will get the same result. --Washuotaku 02:04, 10 December 2008 (UTC)
The items requested seem to be tied to the three nations: Nyumomo Doll - San d'Oria; Gold Beastcoin - Bastok; Lynx Meat - Windurst. Perhaps a similar pattern exists in the answers you can choose from. I didn't write down all the options though, so I can't confirm this. It just seems that answers such as "Culinary delights" (cooking guild), "Green, with envy" (see Shard of Envy from Ark Angel MR) could be related to Windurst and hence lead to Lynx Meat as the required item. The complete set of answers and more individual accounts could shed some more light on this. --.Eithin//T•C 12:02, 10 December 2008 (UTC)
I answered with Mithran Child, Coarse pads, High Places, Blue eyes, Kupoarr, and Savagery. She asked for the Nyumomo Doll. --Zonist 19:43, 10 December 2008 (UTC)
It looks like if you give the true description of Caith Sith will end you asking for the Nyumomo doll... 2 friends and me were asked to retrieve the same item even without telling us the answers lol. Karakuri 19:50, 12 December 2008 (UTC)
I picked the same answers as Maelstorme above: 1. A cat, yet, not a cat 2. Unpleasantly coarse 3. Culinary delights 4. Green, with envy, 5. Meeow, 6. A pair of knee-high bottes. Lilisette asked me for Lynx Meat. Iceday, Waning Crescent. Fiorenzo 19:43, 3 January 2009 (UTC)
I also got same results as Fiorenzo. darksday waning crescent Ryeshinyih 19:25, 6 January 2009 (UTC)
Some information from the Lightning Brigade's testing that there's a points system involved, with each different answer contributing a certain number of points and at the end, the item with the highest points total being requested.--Anthoron T/ C 14:20, 13 February 2009 (UTC)