Thread:Karuberu/@comment-195370-20171019155213/@comment-193051-20171020214239

...Wait, we have labeled section transclusion now? That's awesome! When did we get that? Erm... Sorry. Let me start from the top:

AH Categories
As we talked about before, I'm definitely in favor of splitting out the AH categories from the equipment/craft categories. It's always been a mess and it's even messier now with the new "overflow" categories for Misc. and Alchemy. My only note on that is that I favor a "Weapon (AH)" or "Weapon (Auction House)" naming scheme over "AH Weapon".

Equipment Categories
I'd be thrilled to lose the AH text on equipment category pages. The equipment category pages were originally not AH pages, thus the mixed content, but one of the admins decided they wanted to add that info and noone has really touched it since. I'm not sure where I stand on including the skill-related information. If nothing else, we should include a prominent link to the appropriate pages (skills and weapon skills), but a transclusion of part of those pages might be ok if it doesn't take up too much space.

Stat Categories
One of the reasons I created Stat is so that we can add categories if we want to, but I think we need to consider a policy on what sort of stats should be categorized. I'm definitely in favor of creating skill pages like Sword Skill or pages talking about stat effects like the Latent Effect page. I'm not so sure if we should make a category page for it. I can get into this discussion more if you like, but I'm short on time right now, so I'll leave it at that.

Categorization Guidelines
We should talk about this more when I have some more time. We can probably get away with including parents categories since we don't have very many, but it's something we should talk through, especially when we're thinking of adding more categories.

Equipment Tables
What you're describing sounds good. I'll probably have a few suggestions when you have a prototype made, but the bones of it sound great. I'd kind of like the damage and delay columns to stay, but they can go if width is an issue in the Wikia skin.

As for the item images: if we're lucky, it may be possible to add the section tags around the image through the template. Have you tested that yet? If that's not possible, I'd be glad to add them with Karubot.

We could also transclude the statistics into the table, which would both save a lot of work and help keep the table updated. The statistics templates might cause some issues, but we can work that out (e.g. I can make the auto-categorization disable itself on Category pages).

Template Auto-categorization
We should definitely have proper craft categories and weapon categories and use the Synthesis Recipe, rl, and statistics templates to do it. 200% in favor. Way overdue.