Thread:Karuberu/@comment-195370-20170528222112/@comment-195370-20170630015934

Am currently compiling a spreadsheet here based on the 'Fish' category, the 'Fish' category at BG-Wiki, the master fish list from Kida's site, the fish list on Great Blue, the Fish section of ffxiah.com and what's defined in the dats as a 'fish'. It's all different...

So I wonder how we should go about categorizing Fish? Do we only consider actual animals, and cut out plants like Adoulinian Kelp, or do we stick with actual biological fish and drop things like the Elshimo Frog? Presumably we'd have to include shellfish, but what about crabs and molluscs? How about any living thing in the water, or is a Coral Fragment taking it too far? How about literally any item that can be fished up, so we tag 'Rusty Leggings' with the Fish category? If so, do we also tag all monsters that are fished up too, or just items?

How about Category:Fish is retained just for the AH items under that category (a lot of the newer fish appear under Misc. 2 instead because I guess they're pop items for Escha zones?) and we have a new Category:Fishable for all items and monsters that can be found that encompasses everything?