FFXIclopedia talk:ProblemReports/26544

"These coffers can be opened without this quest active and still receive the attire."

The above statement is incorrect. I just attempted to get BRD legs after never getting them before. I have no current Borghertz's Hands quests active and this one is still listed as a completed quest since I received the BRD hands from killing DS. I obtained my key and returned to Castle O. as BRD/WHM. I opened my chest to receive an Aquamarine... I believe if you have started any other quests for hands for any other job before completing all your original AF for a separate job, you will have to erase the quest and completely start over again.